Are you serious about the NKF poster???
individually, it doesn’t conve any message (not an awareness, not eductional, not call for action)
as a whole, the paitent is oready suffering from kidney problem, you’re not helping them but comparing them with a problematic choked tap.. i assume its just a idea idea scam ads here but, NKF is not a “plumber” to clear the “choked kidney”, they can only help… so i think even as a visual or idea, it still very wrong to show it to the public..
its just my 2cents, please do not take it personal, but i think as a creative we shown to true to the brand, be responsible to the public and be clear to our conscience…
yup, i knew about the incident, but my point is, a poster or an ad is for the organization to either convey a message in order to call for action or to do brand building, thats the only reason why they do a poster and advertise, so do advertiser gonna engage u because u can just rub salt and mock at certain things, and not helping to build brand? i mean if thats what u think poster is about or thats your idea, then i am fine with it…:)
but still, i believe creative should be more responsible…
oh.. ok.. i get what you’re trying to say.. but no worries, as this is a school project that i did during my schooling days, and that’s the theme my lecturer gave me.. thanks for your comments ! appreciate it
Gilbert
March 1, 2010
Are you serious about the NKF poster???
individually, it doesn’t conve any message (not an awareness, not eductional, not call for action)
as a whole, the paitent is oready suffering from kidney problem, you’re not helping them but comparing them with a problematic choked tap.. i assume its just a idea idea scam ads here but, NKF is not a “plumber” to clear the “choked kidney”, they can only help… so i think even as a visual or idea, it still very wrong to show it to the public..
its just my 2cents, please do not take it personal, but i think as a creative we shown to true to the brand, be responsible to the public and be clear to our conscience…
cheers,
qbird
method86
March 1, 2010
ermz, im not sure if u got the message or knew about the NKF incident… this poster is actually to mock about the incident..
Gilbert
March 2, 2010
yup, i knew about the incident, but my point is, a poster or an ad is for the organization to either convey a message in order to call for action or to do brand building, thats the only reason why they do a poster and advertise, so do advertiser gonna engage u because u can just rub salt and mock at certain things, and not helping to build brand? i mean if thats what u think poster is about or thats your idea, then i am fine with it…:)
but still, i believe creative should be more responsible…
method86
March 2, 2010
oh.. ok.. i get what you’re trying to say.. but no worries, as this is a school project that i did during my schooling days, and that’s the theme my lecturer gave me..
thanks for your comments ! appreciate it